Translate

Friday, March 8, 2013

Anything You Can Do I Can Do Better


Anything you can do I can do better; I can do
 anything better than you.

Irving Berlin, composed for Broadway Musical Annie Get Your Gun

Don't underestimate a dangerous woman. And don't judge by appearances; evil can be pleasant and pretty on the outside. Just like poisoned candy.

-Joni E. Johnston, Psy.D.

Murder, sex, revenge, violence, greed, and brutality all fascinate us.

And, when these topics involve women, the public becomes ravenous in its mad search to find yet even more information about how and why these tragedies happen.

Don’t believe me? Turn on the television at any time, or read the newspaper, and you are guaranteed to find stories about women who had too much built up anger, who were twisted time bombs, or just plain evil. 

Our media landscape is scattered with these types of programs.

“Wives with Knives”
“Snapped”
“Deadly Women”

“Whether the motivation was revenge against a cheating husband, the promise of a hefty insurance payoff, or putting an end to years of abuse, the reasons are as varied as the women themselves. From socialites to secretaries, female killers share one thing in common: at some point, they all snapped.”

Snapped, Oxygen Media

The above are but a few of the extraordinarily popular reality television shows that exclusively focus on murderous women.

Like fatal car crashes, train wrecks, and fires, we just can’t bring ourselves to look away.

I confess. I am also enthralled with the Jodi Arias case. I have family and close friends, who all tell me that they watch the televised trial everyday because it is mesmerizing. They just can’t believe that somebody who looks like Jodi Arias could be capable of such brutal savagery. Put me on that list of people who also keep up with the courtroom drama.

If you have seen the news lately, you will generally know that Arias shot her boyfriend and stabbed him almost 30 times. This crime occurred in Arizona, which has the death penalty, and is what prosecutors are seeking as punishment for Arias.

Arias’ position is that that she had a strange sexual relationship with her boyfriend, she had a physical altercation with him, she defended herself, and then her memory is hazy regarding the murderous rampage she inflicted on her boyfriend. There are numerous questions that she has been asked by a very aggressive prosecutor concerning actions she took before and after the murder. She has been unclear and admittedly has many contradictions in her story.

Arias initially told authorities she had nothing to do with Alexander's death then blamed it on masked intruders before settling on self-defense. Her repeated stories to authorities, friends and family in the days after his death, and her efforts to create an alibi and avoid suspicion have been center stage throughout the weeks-long trial.


Arias also detailed for jurors how Alexander grew physically abusive in the months leading up to his death, once choking her into unconsciousness, and how he had sexual desires for young boys.

Arias was asked about past relationships with other men, how easily it would have been to get the gun from the victim's closet as they fought on the day of the killing, and why she worked to clean the crime scene.

Arias said she grabbed the gun from Alexander's closet during a fight at his house, and she was asked how she could have time to retrieve the gun while being chased.

"I just had the sense that he was chasing me," she said.

After killing Alexander, Arias took photos of his bloody corpse and then put the camera in a clothes washer. The jury asked her why she did that.

"I don't know why I would have done that," she said.


Interestingly, I hear comments that the prosecutor is being “too argumentative” in his cross-examination, which may not bode well for the goal of an execution. As a lawyer, there is always very fine line with cross-examination, appearance, and how it affects jurors.

As zealous advocates, lawyers want to get their point across, but do not want to overkill so much that potential points scored during cross-examination are diminished—or worse yet---the jury feels that the attorney is unnecessarily “beating up” on the witness, or repeating questions. This can make a big difference in any case, especially where prosecutors are seeking a death sentence.

Others are excited by the prosecutor, and feel that he is really “sticking it to” Arias by emphasizing her contradictions.

Watching Arias on the stand, it seems unbelievable that this meek, little, person could be capable of such savagery.

"Women are different in whom, how and why they kill," says James Alan Fox, a criminologist at Northeastern University. Though women committed roughly 10 percent of murders between 1976 and 2005, they were involved in nearly 35 percent of murders of intimate partners and nearly 30 percent of murders of where the victim was another family member, according to the Justice Department.

One consistent element, however, which is catnip for a ratings-desperate media, and often perverted public, is sex — and I’m not talking about gender. From Arias and Anthony to Aileen Wournos and the older case of Charlene Gallego, these were women not just accused of murder, but also with a graphic sexual component to all of their cases.

Arias’ testimony often sounded more like a hard core porno movie than a courtroom, as she claimed self-defense alleging (in her third account of what she says really happened) that she was sexually controlled by her now-dead boyfriend, Travis Alexander.

Before her acquittal, Casey Anthony’s sex life and demeanor after her daughter went missing became a focus for the prosecution and media alike.

Serial killer Aileen Wournos’ story is marked by incest, an early pregnancy at age 13, a marriage to a 70-year-old man, a lesbian tryst, and finally, work as a prostitute where she murdered her victims.

In the 1970s, Charlene Gallego was one half of the first known husband and wife serial killer duo, known in the news as the “sex slave killers” because they murdered ten victims, luring some of them into their van where they hog-tied, raped and killed them. 
Quoting, Dan Abrams

While statistics of murderous women differ, there are generally nine categories of women who kill. These are listed as follows:

Black Widow – systematically kills multiple spouses, partners, or other family members.
Team Killer – kills or participates in the killing of others in conjunction with at least one other.
Angel of Death – systematically kills people who are in her care for some form of medical attention
Question of Sanity – kills in apparent random manner and later judged to be insane.
Sexual Predator – systematically kills others in clear acts of sexual homicide.
Unexplained – kills for reasons that are totally inexplicable or for unclear motives.
Revenge – systematically kills out of hate or jealousy
Unsolved -a pattern of unsolved killings that may be attributed to a woman (or women)
Profit or Crime – systematically kills for profit or in course of committing another crime

Quoting, Michael & C. Kelleher (1998)


Says Dan Abrams, “A young, attractive woman accused of murder is interesting, in particular, because it’s rare and defies many societal expectations. This is not to justify the coverage, but rather to simply articulate the reality. They make good copy, great headlines, and often compelling television and even movies. However, let’s take care not to lay all the blame on the media. The media wouldn’t focus on female killers if it didn’t have a partner in crime, a public obsessed with evaluating, understanding and ultimately judging these women accused of the most heinous of crimes.”  

So, why are we unable to look away from the horrific murders committed by women?

It is perhaps best put by Carrie Gunter, “we're searching for that monster within the pretty exterior, hoping it's something that we'll eventually be able to identify. All of the childhood stories indicated evil as ugly, right? We never expect to see such ugliness/evil in a (outward appearing) beautiful person.”


-Leonardo G. Renaud

Friday, March 1, 2013

Run From The “Blade Runner”




“A sociopath is one who sees others as impersonal objects to be manipulated to fulfill their own narcissistic needs without any regard for the hurtful consequences of their selfish actions."


~R. Alan Woods

While I always attempt to keep an objective perspective in my posts, in my opinion based on all of the facts and information I have read about the death of Reeva Steenkamp, Oscar Pistorius is a murderer. His sense of self-entitlement and constant adulation from the public only stoked his tremendous ego and delirious concept of himself. He is a person who feels that he can do whatever he wants and get away with it. Can you say OJ Simpson? (at least OJ is now in prison for something) I hope, on behalf of the young lady he slaughtered, that the public does not continue to be enamored with him, and that he spend the rest of his miserable life in prison.

Let me tell you why I believe the above about the “Blade Runner.”

When I watched Oscar Pistorius run in these past Olympics, I was deeply moved by the fact that he had overcome so many obstacles in his life to reach his goals. Being a world class track star with no legs was simply amazing to me. The trials and tribulations he overcame in his life gave me such inspiration. Knowing that if a person really believes in themselves, and works hard towards a seemingly impossible goal, makes them a hero.  I was so proud and happy for him. By all accounts, all South Africans also considered him a hero and placed him on a towering pedestal, which glorifies everything that is good and pure about sports. The concept of overcoming overwhelming odds and reaching success is a story that deeply resonates with all of us.

I must admit, that when the story broke that his beautiful, educated girlfriend, Reeva Steenkamp, had been killed in his home, I initially did not pay much attention to the media coverage. Since we are constantly blasted by news day and night, and in all different manners, I have been admittedly desensitized and rarely pay attention to the news. Like a lot of people, I assumed that some burglar broke into Pistorius’ house. Fearing for his safety, he fired shots to protect himself. Sadly, the person on the other side of the door was his girlfriend, and she was killed. It wasn’t until I started hearing arguments and heated discussions that I decided that I would take a closer look.

Facts About The Case

The pertinent facts are as follows:

Early on Valentine's Day morning, Oscar Pistorius, the double-amputee Olympian who is arguably South Africa's biggest sporting star, shot through a bathroom door at his home in Pretoria and killed his girlfriend, 29-year-old model and law school graduate Reeva Steenkamp.

Pistorius says he walked to the bathroom on his stumps, and then shot through the door. Investigators say the angle of the bullet holes suggest Pistorius was standing tall on his prosthetics. The police theory, they claim, gives credence to a charge of premeditation. If Pistorius had time to put on his prosthetics, they'll argue, then he wasn't getting out of bed quickly to pursue an intruder.

A front page article in The Times (of South Africa) quoted a police officer who said he had contact with Pistorius after Wednesday's hearings. "He's convinced he'll be out by the weekend and back on the track before the end of the year," the officer said. Would an innocent man be that confident? Could a guilty man be that delusional? If that quote is accurate, psychologists could have a field day dissecting it.

Police found two boxes of testosterone, syringes and needles in a bedroom cabinet. Later, a police spokesman admitted the contents of the box were unknown. Testosterone is a banned substance by the IOC. The defense says the boxes contained an herbal remedy commonly used for sexual enhancement purposes. Pistorius is 26 years old.

Pistorius has argued in court that he was closing his balcony doors Feb. 14 when he heard a noise from the bathroom. Fearing an intruder, and without his prosthetic legs on, he grabbed a gun from under his bed and fired through the closed bathroom door, he told the court.

But prosecutors say that's implausible, arguing that the gun's holster was found under the side of the bed where Steenkamp was sleeping, and that Pistorius would have seen she wasn't there.

Prosecutors argue that Pistorius, a double-amputee, took the time to put on his carbon-fiber prosthetic legs and walk to the bathroom, where he fired the gun, hitting Steenkamp three times. Their insistence that Pistorius took a moment to put the legs on indicates that he thought out and planned to kill Steenkamp.

There was a "deliberate aiming of shots at the toilet from about 1.5 meters [about 5 feet]," prosecutor Gerrie Nel said.

They also say the angle at which the shots were fired shows that Pistorius was already wearing his prosthetics when he fired.

"[The angle] seems to me down. Fired down," officers told the court Feb. 20, suggesting that Pistorius was standing high up on his artificial legs.

Pistorius says he did not put on the prosthetics, and was on his stumps, and felt vulnerable when he shot through the bathroom door.

Police said no calls to the police or ambulance service were made on any of the four cell phones -- two iPhones and two BlackBerrys -- found in the bathroom and bedroom of Pistorius' home. Investigators said that guards at the gated estate called Pistorius, who told them he was "all right." The call was not disconnected and they could hear him crying, police said.

Pistorius says he called the manager of the housing estate, and asked him to place a call for an ambulance. He says that he also called a private paramedic service. According to his lawyers, there was a fifth phone that Pistorius used to make the calls.

There had been previous incidents at his house involving allegations of domestic violence.

My thoughts regarding the above information is, if he knew that his girlfriend was sleeping at his house, why would he not confirm it was her by yelling her name out loud, or asking if it was her through the bathroom door?  After all, he was armed with a gun.

Why did he shoot four bullets through a bathroom door---without having a clue where his girlfriend was located in the house? Also, why would he not immediately call the police or an ambulance after finding his girlfriend shot to death? Why were all of the shots perfectly aimed at the upper body and head?

Finally, if he did have his prosthetics on, which he does not sleep with, why would he take the trouble to put them on if he truly thought there was an intruder in the house? It takes time to put prosthetics on, and by all accounts he can easily move without them.

The savage shooting that occurred in this case, prompted a long conversation with my wife wherein we discussed how many women are either abused or killed by spouses or significant others.  I think the following statistics are going to shock you, the way they did to us. We had absolutely no idea of the following:

According to domesticviolencestatistics.org,
  • Every 9 seconds in the US a woman is assaulted or beaten.
  • Around the world, at least one in every three women has been beaten, coerced into sex or otherwise abused during her lifetime. Most often, the abuser is a member of her own family.
  • Domestic violence is the leading cause of injury to women—more than car accidents, muggings, and rapes combined.
  • Studies suggest that up to 10 million children witness some form of domestic violence annually.
  • Nearly 1 in 5 teenage girls who have been in a relationship said a boyfriend threatened violence or self-harm if presented with a breakup.
  • Everyday in the US, more than three women are murdered by their husbands or boyfriends.
  • Ninety-two percent of women surveyed listed reducing domestic violence and sexual assault as their top concern.
  • Domestic violence victims lose nearly 8 million days of paid work per year in the US alone—the equivalent of 32,000 full-time jobs.
  • Based on reports from 10 countries, between 55 percent and 95 percent of women who had been physically abused by their partners had never contacted non-governmental organizations, shelters, or the police for help.
  • The costs of intimate partner violence in the US alone exceed $5.8 billion per year: $4.1 billion are for direct medical and health care services, while productivity losses account for nearly $1.8 billion.
  • Men who as children witnessed their parents’ domestic violence were twice as likely to abuse their own wives than sons of nonviolent parents.
  • In a 1995-1996 study conducted in the 50 States and the District of Columbia, nearly 25% of women and 7.6% of men were raped and/or physically assaulted by a current or former spouse, cohabiting partner, or dating partner/acquaintance at some time in their lifetime (based on survey of 16,000 participants, equally male and female).
Patricia Tjaden & Nancy Thoennes, U.S. Dep't of Just., NCJ 181867, Extent, Nature, and Consequences of Intimate Partner Violence, at iii (2000), available at http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/nij/pubs-sum/181867.htm
  • Approximately 1.3 million women and 835,000 men are physically assaulted by an intimate partner annually in the United States.
Patricia Tjaden & Nancy Thoennes, U.S. Dep't of Just., NCJ 183781, Full Report of the Prevalence, Incidence, and Consequences of Intimate Partner Violence Against Women: Findings from the National Violence Against Women Survey, at iv (2000), available at http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/nij/pubs-sum/183781.htm

Traits of Professional Athletes

As I continued to hear about the shocking statistics of domestic violence and murders, I decided to also learn more about Pistorius. I wanted to learn more about the man, whom I had greatly admired, along with all of South Africa. I also wanted to examine whether his status as an elite athlete may have impacted his actions on the night that his girlfriend was killed.

There are 12 predominant traits of an abuser. These are as follows: 1)Charming; 2)Jealous; 3) Manipulative; 4) Controlling; 5) Claim to be a Victim; 6) Narcissistic; 7) Inconsistent; 8) Critical; 9) Disconnected; 10) Hypersensitive; 11) Vicious and Cruel; 12) Insincerely Repentant. 

Quoting, Laura Petherbridge, 12 Traits of an Abuser.

There is no question that elite athletes are narcissistic men. They have to be because anybody in the pursuit of greatness are people whom the ends always justify the means. The problem with the mythologizing of professional athletes, is the notion that they stand for something special beyond the field of play. They don’t, but that doesn’t stop us from trying to make them equal to the image we insist on having for them. This often affects their personal decisions wherein they believe that they are above the rest of us and deserve to get and do whatever they want. There is selfish entitlement that comes with nonsensical idolatry that seals them in an airtight bubble regardless of their feigned ability to act humble in post game interviews.

Pistorius also liked adrenaline rushes. He liked to drive cars 155 miles per hour on wet roads, crashed his speed boat requiring 172 stitches, had a huge interest in guns and shooting, and kept dangerous animals as pets.

Quoting, Buzz Bissinger., The Unwarranted Mythology of Oscar Pistorius.

According to uk.eurosport.yahoo.com, Pistorius was accused in 2012 of threatening to cause bodily violence against another man whom he accused of cheating with his girlfriend. The man who Pistorius threatened stated that the girl at the center of the controversy was not even Pistorius’ girlfriend, and admitted that he was “scared for his life.” A charge of defamation was also brought against Pistorius. As it stands, both men have made conflicting accusations against each other.

Oscar Pistorius subjected Reeva Steenkamp to such intense emotional pressure in the early days of the relationship that her best friend's father was forced to warm him to "back off". 

Cecil Myers, who Miss Steenkamp lived with in Johannesburg said he had found Pistorius to be "very moody" as he wooed the young model who felt caged in by his attentions. 

"Very nice and charming to us when they started dating. Then he always came in to say hello. But when they began to date steadily, he just dropped her and picked her up. 

"That's not right. I call it respect. If you're in a relationship and you pick up the 'daughter' in the house, at least come in and say hello." After the couple's first date, Pistorius "would not leave her alone," Mr. Myers said. 

"He kept pestering her, phoning and phoning and phoning her. Oscar was hasty and impatient and very moody – that's my impression of him.

"She told me he pushed her a bit into a corner. She felt caged in.”

"She was my little girl, and he shot her four times from behind a closed door,” Mr. Myers said.

Miss Steenkamp had lived with Mr. Myers, a commercial printer, and his wife Desi since September, and the couple's daughter Kim was the model's closest friend in the city. 

People will stay away from him now. Women too, they will be too afraid, no girl wants to risk being killed. And if my daughter wanted to go out with him, the shi[_]would hit the proverbial fan. Mr. Myers said he had decided to talk to the newspaper because, "everywhere you go, it's just Oscar, Oscar". 

"Reeva was the victim, her voice must be heard too. People must know who Reeva Steenkamp was," he said. 

Miss Steenkamp did not originally plan to stay with Oscar Pistorius the night she died but changed her mind because it became too late for her to drive home safely, her best friend's father has said. 

Miss Steenkamp, who grew up in Port Elizabeth, used to introduce him to her friends as her "Joburg dad". 

"I've got this thing with all three children (Reeva, and his daughters, Kim and Gina), if they don't come home at night, they must text me," Mr. Myers told South Africa's City Press newspaper. 

"Then Reeva sent the (SMS) message: 'Hi guys, I'm too tired. It's too far to drive. I'm sleeping at Oscar's tonight. See you tomorrow'. 

"Tomorrow never dawned for her I have nightmares at night thinking how frightened she must have been. Can you imagine how terrified she was?" 

Quoting, Mike Pflanz

Conclusion

I know they teach you in law school that a person’s guilt must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt, etc. But, often when you walk into a courthouse, the lawyers will tell you that you follow the law, but you do not leave your common sense outside the courtroom door. 

Given the overwhelming facts that have been provided, there is absolutely no question in my mind that this animal killed Reeva Steenkamp. She unfortunately crossed paths with a homicidal killer. One can only hope that the fascination with Pestorius’ story and legend does not outweigh the terror that abruptly ended a young girl’s life. While he showed that he did accomplish greatness in sport, this does not transcend all of the facts that show, in the end, he is just another plain killer.

Will celebrity outweigh tragedy? Keeping my fingers crossed it doesn’t.


~Leonardo G. Renaud

Friday, February 22, 2013

Cruise Vacations: Sailing into “The Heart of Darkness.”



“What doesn’t kill us makes us bitter.”



~Chuck Lorre



Over the past few days, the media has been all abuzz about the ill fated Carnival Triumph cruise ship that caught fire, resulting in an inoperable engine, major plumbing back ups, raw sewage leaks, and damage to the extent that the ship had to be pulled via tugboat for days to Alabama. While there are ports in Mexico much closer than Alabama, Carnival has failed to provide any clear explanation why it chose to dock its ship in Alabama. There are those who believe this was done purely for economic reasons, although the entire incident is still under investigation.


Passengers generally describe the conditions of the ship as horribly abysmal. Among other numerous problems, there were stinking, feces filled, and flooded hallways. People were forced to relieve themselves in plastic bags. The stabilizers on the ship also did not work. This caused the ship to violently rock from side to side for days, spilling human waste and garbage throughout the hallways. Those suffering from seasickness must have felt like they were on an evil nonstop vomit producing merry go round.


There were also problems getting unspoiled food to the thousands of passengers, causing near riots, fights, and complaints of constant hunger. The passengers slept on the upper decks covered with towels because the flooding and stench of the lower decks was intolerable.


Passengers who were on the ship for their honeymoon, birthday, anniversary, and other special occasions all had their vacations completely ruined. Many of the passengers state that they will never again travel on a cruise ship. Their entire view of travel by ship is scarred forever.

As compensation, Carnival has offered a refund for the cruise, credit towards a future booking, travel expense reimbursement, and $500.00 per passenger.


What is the likelihood of passengers prevailing if they decide to file lawsuits against the cruise line? It appears that a passenger’s chance of obtaining any large amount of money recovery is highly uncertain.


To begin with, a passenger suing Carnival will have to prove some type of “physical injury.”


Cruise line tickets prohibit passengers from suing over emotional distress, without any form of personal injury. This provision is contained in the numerous pages of conditions that accompany each cruise ticket. Cruise tickets go largely unread by travelers, although they are binding contracts.

Tickets issued by Carnival and other similar cruise line companies contain strict time limits, language limiting how a passenger may recover any damages, and also set the location of the court where any lawsuit can be filed. The location typically heavily favors the cruise line company. For example, passengers may live in Alaska and injured on the open sea, but if they want to sue Carnival, they have to file their lawsuit in Miami. This also makes the case more expensive because depositions, hearings, inspections, and trials must take place in Miami.

Gerald McGill, a plaintiff’s lawyer in Pensacola, Florida, who specializes in maritime cases, says it seems unlikely that passengers on the Carnival Triumph will be able to recover damages for distress because they also have to show physical injury. Simply put, the constant state of fear, smell of feces and exposure to potentially diseased squalor, may not be sufficient, in and of itself, to constitute a physical “injury.”

Notwithstanding existing obstacles, Plaintiff attorneys are not discouraged by the limitation language on the cruise tickets.


While there have been no physical injuries, if a person contracted a disease from unsanitary conditions on the ship, they could argue for physical injury, maritime trial attorney John H. Hickey told CNN. And due to the conditions on board, many could have been at risk of these diseases.


“I think that a case can be made that everyone on that ship is at risk of actual physical injury,” he said, adding that the cruise line will no doubt want to diffuse the situation as quickly as possible.

 
Additionally, a Florida maritime law firm has filed a class-action lawsuit on behalf of passengers aboard the Carnival Triumph.

The lawsuit, filed on Feb. 18 in the  United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida, claims that Carnival was negligent for allowing the Carnival Triumph to embark on the failed five-day cruise when the company was aware the ship was prone to mechanical and/or engine issues.


Attorneys at Miami-based Lipcon, Margulies, Alsina & Winkleman filed the lawsuit on behalf of passengers Matt and Melissa Crusan of Oklahoma, and more than 100 other passengers aboard the vessel. Most of the plaintiffs in the lawsuit are from Texas, according to attorney Mike Winkleman.

 
From Feb. 10 to 15, the lawsuit states, passengers "were forced to sleep on deck and/or in other communal areas on the vessel, relieve themselves into buckets, bags, showers, sinks, were given spoiled or rotting food that was unfit for reasonable safe human consumption, and were generally forced to live in squalid conditions that created a severe risk of injury, illness and/or disease."

Due to the lack of working plumbing and sanitation systems on the ship, the petition states, "sewage and/or putrid water filled with urine and feces leaked onto floors, walls, and ceilings. This sewage and/or human waste sloshed around the vessel as the vessel listed while drifting and/or while under tow."

 
"Conditions became increasingly unbearable each day," the lawsuit alleges, "due to the lack of a working ventilation system on the vessel, leading to noxious odors and gasses that caused numerous passengers to vomit and/or become nauseous."

The lawsuit also charges that Carnival's decision to tow the Triumph to
Mobile, instead of to the closer port of Progreso, Mexico, caused passengers to endure more time aboard the disabled vessel than necessary, prolonging their ordeal.

"The primary motivation for that (decision) was money," Winkleman said. "It was much cheaper for Carnival to tow the ship to Mobile where it would be repaired, rather than (have it towed) to Mexico and have another tow (from there) back to Alabama. It's cheaper to put 3,000 people on buses to Galveston than to have to fly them from Mexico."

Quoting, Robert Stanton, “Class-action lawsuit filed in cruise ship fiasco.”

 
"I think people are going to file suits and rightly so," maritime trial attorney John Hickey told ABCNews.com. "I think, frankly, that the conduct of Carnival has been outrageous from the get-go."

Hickey, a Miami-based attorney, said his firm has already received "quite a few" inquiries from passengers who just got off the ship.

"What you have here is a) negligence on the part of Carnival and b) you have them, the passengers, being exposed to the risk of actual physical injury," Hickey said.

The attorney said that whether passengers can recover monetary compensation will depend on maritime law and the 15-pages of legal "gobbledygook," as Hickey described it, that passengers signed before boarding, but "nobody really agrees to."

One of the ticket requirements is that class action lawsuits are not allowed, but Hickey say there is a possibility that clause could be voided when all the conditions of the situation are taken into account.

Notwithstanding the aggressive creativity of numerous Plaintiff lawyers, who certainly are not going to give up easily, other maritime lawyers familiar with cruise ship lawsuits suggest angry passengers should think twice before rushing to the courts. Unless passengers suffered major injuries or other losses due to negligence by the cruise operator, they may be better off accepting compensation from Carnival.


Some lawyers’ opinions are that even if monetary damages are obtained by a Plaintiff lawyer, it will likely be so minimal that waiting for the lawsuit to finish, plus the fees and costs that the attorneys will subtract for themselves, is just not worth the time, aggravation, and effort that will be spent by a passenger.


"The cruise lines want each person to have to go to arbitration and get a lawyer and spend money," said attorney Adam Brum of Morgan & Morgan in Miami, who has talked to several passengers but hasn't filed a case yet. "It makes it very hard."


The success that passengers may have with their lawsuits against Carnival will depend on whether Plaintiff attorneys can convince the courts that the numerous limitations on cruise tickets are unfair, or that the facts of their client’s particular case do not fall within the limitations set forth in the cruise ticket.


The bottom line is, if travelers do not want to waive all of their potential rights that cruise lines have (rather sneakily) created as litigation obstacles, it may be a better option to take a nice road trip like the good old days with mom and dad.


Bon voyage!



~Leonardo G. Renaud